Current Topics
High Schoolers acting out
by Spag-hetti
Today at 03:32 PM
Trump takes title from Buchanan!
by Spag-hetti
Today at 03:09 PM
Dems poised to gain seats after court throws out Pa. congressional map
by Spag-hetti
Today at 03:05 PM
Trump and Russia
by rporter314
Yesterday at 10:19 PM
Round Table for January, 2018
by pondering_it_all
Yesterday at 08:25 PM
Rod Rosenstein's Innoculation
by pondering_it_all
Yesterday at 07:56 PM
The Question
by jgw
Yesterday at 07:08 PM
Why canít Star Trek: Discovery commit to serialized storytelling?
by Golem
Yesterday at 02:51 AM
Trump works hard to support the NRA
by jgw
02/18/18 10:28 PM
The Electoral College Subverts the Will of the Majority Vote
by Spag-hetti
02/17/18 01:05 AM
DACA
by jgw
02/15/18 10:37 PM
The Onion's take
by jgw
02/15/18 10:19 PM
Whatever happened to rational conservatism?
by chunkstyle
02/15/18 05:51 PM
The Passing Parade: Obituaries: 2018
by Jeffery J. Haas
02/10/18 12:33 AM
We All have Immigrant Roots
by Jeffery J. Haas
02/09/18 09:13 PM
Susan Sheu and Brian Colker, former NYT subscribers
by pdx rick
02/08/18 01:24 AM
Happy Shutdown Day
by NW Ponderer
02/07/18 01:43 PM
Ronda Rousey joining WWE to perform as full-time pro wrestler
by Greger
02/07/18 12:27 AM
Memo to the Public: The President Wants to Make the FBI His Instrument
by Jeffery J. Haas
02/05/18 10:32 PM
Underclass
by jgw
02/05/18 06:46 PM
Forum Stats
6248 Members
58 Forums
16190 Topics
279053 Posts

Max Online: 294 @ 12/06/17 12:57 AM
Google Adsense
Topic Options
#267035 - 12/29/13 02:31 PM Why didn't George Z stick with a SYG defense?
logtroll Offline
veteran

Registered: 04/26/10
Posts: 8729
Loc: New Mexico (not old Mexico)
Was SYG not applicable? (he did claim that TM was endangering his life so he shot him.)

He got off on self-defense, so what use was the SYG law?

His behavior was arguably "not responsible" in that he pursued TM against the advice of the police dispatcher; so neither SYG, nor the self-defense law proved to be stimulus for acting responsibly. "Duty to retreat" does appear to be a stimulus for acting responsibly, in the form of acting to de-escalate rather that escalate a situation. "Standing your ground", if there is an opportunity to retreat, is a form of escalation... is SYG really just an expression of testosterone, substituting a gun for a private piece of male anatomy?

Was George Z "defending his castle" (mobile version, no duty to retreat, not even any duty to not pursue...)?

I find this thing of finding excuses for shooting unarmed people to be very difficult to understand. (That was an opening for Isso to find agreement with my self-assessment of low intelligence. However, I am smart enough to not be packing' and looking for ground to stand on with me trusty shooting' iron.)
_________________________
"You can't fix a problem until you understand what the problem is." Logtroll

Top
#267036 - 12/29/13 03:04 PM Re: Why didn't George Z stick with a SYG defense? [Re: logtroll]
pdx rick Offline
Member
Carpal Tunnel

Registered: 05/09/05
Posts: 40768
Loc: Puget Sound, WA

It is true that GZ did not use SYG in his defense. However, the Judge gave the jury instructions to use SYG and that's how GZ got off.
_________________________
Contrarian, extraordinaire



Top
#267052 - 12/29/13 09:25 PM Re: Why didn't George Z stick with a SYG defense? [Re: logtroll]
issodhos Offline
Pooh-Bah

Registered: 09/29/05
Posts: 12581
Originally Posted By: logtroll
Was SYG not applicable? (he did claim that TM was endangering his life so he shot him.)

He got off on self-defense, so what use was the SYG law?


In the case of Zimmerman, SYG was irrelevant because he was pinned to the ground and in no position to flee. Since "stand your ground" provides protection against any duty to retreat when certain conditions are met, and retreat was not possible according to the evidence presented, a standard self-defense strategy was more than adequate. In cases where retreat was possible, but not taken, it would then be useful to the defense -- or, so I would think.
Yours,
Issodhos
_________________________
"When all has been said that can be said, and all has been done that can be done, there will be poetry";-) -- Issodhos

Top
#267053 - 12/29/13 09:37 PM Re: Why didn't George Z stick with a SYG defense? [Re: pdx rick]
issodhos Offline
Pooh-Bah

Registered: 09/29/05
Posts: 12581
Originally Posted By: california rick

It is true that GZ did not use SYG in his defense. However, the Judge gave the jury instructions to use SYG and that's how GZ got off.


As I understand it, rick, that is a part of the standard instructions given to jurors in self-defense cases in Florida. They are free to determine it's applicability, as well as the applicability of a number of other instructions, drawing their ultimate conclusion based on the evidence presented in the trial. At no point before or during the trial was "Stand Your Ground" used by the defense as a defense or as a basis and support for invoking a demand for immunity. He walked based on plain ol' self-defense law.
Yours,
Issodhos
_________________________
"When all has been said that can be said, and all has been done that can be done, there will be poetry";-) -- Issodhos

Top
#267062 - 12/30/13 12:27 AM Re: Why didn't George Z stick with a SYG defense? [Re: issodhos]
logtroll Offline
veteran

Registered: 04/26/10
Posts: 8729
Loc: New Mexico (not old Mexico)
So what reason is there for the SYG law? (I'm not going to ask more than ten times...)
_________________________
"You can't fix a problem until you understand what the problem is." Logtroll

Top

Who's Online
0 registered (), 42 Guests and 2 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Newest Members
TrentonP, Nosf50, erumonej, Jensen Breck, Albertapkr
6248 Registered Users
A2